Eskom has admitted to exceeding stage 4 load-shedding limits, which energy advisor Ted Blom said shows the power utility is lying about which stage they have implemented.
This year, South Africa experienced the worst load-shedding it has ever seen, with 49 days of blackouts to date.
According to Eskom’s announcements, load-shedding peaked at stage 4, but Blom highlighted that the power utility exceeded stage 4 in September.
Official information shared by Eskom showed load-shedding of 5,359MW on Wednesday 2 September and 5,642MW on Thursday 3 September.
This far exceeds stage 4 load-shedding, which “allows for up to 4,000MW of the national load to be shed”.
Eskom spokesperson Sikonathi Mantshantsha denied accusations that Eskom is deliberately deceiving the public on which load-shedding stages it is implementing.
He confirmed the accuracy of the load-shedding statistics published on 2 and 3 September but said load curtailment should also be taken into consideration.
“Once Eskom declares Stage 4 load-shedding, it can request any major industrial customer to curtail up to 20% of load,” Mantshantsha said.
“This amounts to 1,200MW of demand that must be curtailed by industrial customers as part of the licenced load curtailment in terms.”
“Load-shedding is what Eskom sheds from the public, and that is what Eskom announced at Stage 4 on Thursday.”
However, when pushed on the amount of load-shedding which truly happened on Thursday, Mantshantsha said “Eskom did shed 4,400MW on the day in question”.
This equates to stage 5 load-shedding based on Eskom’s own definitions. Mantshantsha, however, would not answer the question on whether the power utility implemented stage 5 load-shedding.
It is not clear why Eskom refused to admit it implemented stage 5 load-shedding, as this could cause confusion among consumers.
Blom accused Eskom of being deceitful in its answers and trying to downplay the severity of load-shedding in South Africa.
Eskom’s load-shedding stage definitions
Eskom explains the different load-shedding stages on its website and in the documentation it provides to the public and municipalities.
Here are the current load-shedding definitions for Stage 1 to Stage 8.
- Stage 1 allows for up to 1,000 MW of the national load to be shed.
- Stage 2 allows for up to 2,000 MW of the national load to be shed.
- Stage 3 allows for up to 3,000 MW of the national load to be shed.
- Stage 4 allows for up to 4,000 MW of the national load to be shed.
- Stage 5 allows for up to 5,000 MW of the national load to be shed.
- Stage 6 allows for up to 6,000 MW of the national load to be shed.
- Stage 7 allows for up to 7,000 MW of the national load to be shed.
- Stage 8 allows for up to 8,000 MW of the national load to be shed.
According to these definitions, and after taking 1,200MW load curtailment into account, stage 5 load-shedding was implemented on 2 September and 3 September.
The table below provides an overview of the load-shedding implemented in the beginning of September.
| Eskom load-shedding | |||
| Date | Load shed | What Eskom announced | Load-shedding definition |
| 1 September | 2,192MW | Stage 2 | Stage 3 |
| 2 September | 5,359MW | Stage 4 | Stage 5 (with curtailment) |
| 3 September | 5,642MW | Stage 4 | Stage 5 (with curtailment) |
| 4 September | 3,114MW | Stage 3 | Stage 4 |
Eskom should be honest with the public – Blom
Blom said there is a “massive difference between being forced to shed 4,000MW (13%) of total demand and 6,000MW (20%)”.
“If the power utility is short of 20% of the economy’s need it is a national disaster and requires an immediate intervention,” he said.
According to Blom, Eskom has lied to the public on load-shedding days this year and on the level of load-shedding.
He added that Eskom is also not telling the truth on how long the reconditioning program will take and the level of reconditioning done during lockdown level 5.
“In short, the public has branded Eskom as pathological liars with many examples over the last decade,” said Blom.
Blom said Eskom’s leadership should take extra precautions to ensure they are “100% factually correct and stop playing cat and mouse with the public”.
Sikonathi Mantshantsha load-shedding data
Evening Peak Feedback on 01/09/2020
Total demand: 32 327MW at 18:33
Loadshedding: 2 192MW
Number of @Eskom_SA Open Cycle Gas Turbines: 14
Independent Power Producer OCGT’s: 6
Renewable Generation: 1 146MW (Wind 954MW, CSP 192MW)
Eskom supply: 30 060MW— SikonathiMantshantsh (@SikonathiM) September 1, 2020
Evening Peak Feedback
Total Peak Demand at 18:28 on 02/09/2020:
33 359MW
Loadshedding: 5 359MW
Number of @Eskom_SA Open Cycle Gas Turbines utilised: 9
Number of IPP OCGT’s Utilised: 6
Renewable Generation: 699MW (Wind 546MW, CSP 153MW)
Eskom Available Supply: 30 755MW— SikonathiMantshantsh (@SikonathiM) September 2, 2020
Evening Peak Feedback on 03/09/2020 at 18:39
Total demand: 33 638MW
Loadshedding: 5 642MW
Renewable Generation: 726MW (Wind 520MW, CSP 206MW)
Open Cycle Gas Turbines Not Utilised@Eskom_SA Available Generation: 30 251MW— SikonathiMantshantsh (@SikonathiM) September 3, 2020
Evening Peak Feedback 04/09/2020 at 18:41
Total Demand: 30 164MW
Number of OCGT’s Utilised: 0
Loadshedding: 3 114MW
Renewable Generation: 803MW (Wind 637MW, CSP 166MW)@Eskom_SA Supply: 29 436MW— SikonathiMantshantsh (@SikonathiM) September 4, 2020